Plata v. Newsom
Case Summary
In 2001, the Prison Law Office filed a federal class action lawsuit on behalf of every person incarcerated in CDCR who has a serious medical condition, because there were serious problems with medical care at every CDCR prison. In 2002, the federal court in the Plata case ordered CDCR to make major changes to medical care and to follow specific written policies and procedures (links to current medical care rules and policies are below). In 2005, the court found that CDCR could not improve medical care on its own, and the court appointed an independent Receiver with authority over CDCR medical care.
In 2009, a three-judge federal court determined that CDCR would be unable to provide constitutionally adequate health care so long as the prisons were grossly overcrowded and ordered CDCR to reduce crowding statewide to 137.5% of design capacity. In 2011, that order was affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court.
In 2014, the three-judge court ordered CDCR to implement specific population reduction measures, including increased time credits and parole consideration for elder incarcerated people and people with convictions for non-violent offenses. As a result of these and other measures, the CDCR institutions population is approximately 86,000, compared with approximately 160,000 in 2006. The CDCR institutions’ population statewide is at approximately 130% of current design capacity.
In addition, starting in 2012, CDCR undertook a project to remodel or build new medical clinics at all prisons (the project is scheduled to be completed in mid-2027). In 2013, the California Health Care Facility was opened, with more than 1,000 inpatient beds.
In 2015, the court ordered the Receiver to consider returning control of medical care at each prison back to CDCR. As of October 2026, the Receiver has done so for all except three prisons. The Receiver still has overall authority for medical care in CDCR.
CDCR self-reports compliance with certain medical care requirements via a public Dashboard. The independent Office of the Inspector General conducts and publishes periodic evaluations of medical care at each prison. We continue to monitor medical care in CDCR and advocate regarding both systemic and patient-specific issues.
Timeline
| April 2001 | Incarcerated people sue California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) for its failure to provide constitutionally adequate medical care. |
| June 2002 | Parties agree to and the federal court orders injunctive relief, requiring CDCR to provide the level of medical care required under the Eighth Amendment, including by following specific policies and procedures. |
| May 2005 | The federal court finds "the California prison medical care system is broken beyond repair" and appoints an independent Receiver with authority over CDCR medical care. |
| October 2006 | Governor Schwarzenegger issues "Prison Overcrowding State of Emergency Proclamation" based on severe overcrowding in 29 out of 33 prisons. |
| November 2006 | Plaintiffs move to convene a federal three-judge court to address severe overcrowding in California prisons. More than 160,000 people were incarcerated in CDCR. |
| July 2007 | Three-judge court convenes. |
| March 2009 | CDCR's request to terminate the receivership is denied; Court finds Receivership complies with the federal Prison Litigation Reform Act. |
| August 2009 | Three-judge court finds "crowding is the primary cause of the state’s unconstitutional failure to provide adequate medical and mental health care" and orders CDCR to reduce the prison population to 137.5% of design capacity. |
| May 2011 | U.S. Supreme Court affirms the three-judge court decision regarding population reduction. |
| January 2012 | The Receiver and CDCR begin a project to remodel or build new medical clinics and associated areas at all prisons. The project is scheduled to be completed in mid-2027. |
| April 2013 | Three-judge court denies CDCR's request to vacate the population reduction order and threatens contempt if CDCR does not act to comply with the order. |
| June 2013 | Plaintiffs' request for relief related to Valley Fever is granted. Strict requirements are placed on who can be housed at two specific prisons. |
| July 2013 | The California Health Care Facility opens, with more than 1,000 inpatient beds. |
| February 2014 | Three-judge court orders CDCR to implement specific population reduction measures, including increased time credits for certain incarcerated people and early parole consideration for elderly residents and those serving terms for non-violent offenses. |
| February 2015 | CDCR meets the 137.5% population benchmark. |
| March 2015 | Federal court orders Receiver to consider returning authority for medical care at each prison back to CDCR. |
| January 2020 | CDCR begins to implement the Integrated Substance Use Disorder Treatment (ISUDT) Program. As of late 2026, about 20,000 people in CDCR were receiving medication-assisted treatment through the ISUDT program. |
| March - April 2020 | COVID hits California prisons. Plaintiffs file an emergency request with the three-judge court for population reduction in response to COVID; three-judge court denies Plaintiffs' request for emergency relief. Plaintiffs request emergency relief related to COVID at the district court level; that request is also denied. |
| September 2021 - April 2022 | District court issues order mandating COVID vaccinations for CDCR staff, and the Ninth Circuit vacates the vaccination order. |
| October 2026 | As of October 2026, the Receiver has returned authority for medical care to CDCR at all but three prisons and retains authority over statewide medical issues. CDCR’s statewide institutions population is approximately 86,000, approximately 130% of current design capacity. |
Documents & Resources
Important Litigation Documents
Order to Show Cause re Civil Contempt and Appointment of Interim Receiver (May 10, 2005)
Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law re Appointment of Receiver (October 3, 2005)
Order re Receivership Transition Plan and Expert Evaluations (September 5, 2012)
Order Modifying Receivership Transition Plan (March 10, 2015)
Defendants’ October 2016 Status Report to the Three-Judge Court (October 17, 2026)
Order Modifying Paragraph 4(C) of March 10, 2015 Transition Plan Order (May 9, 2018)
Order Modifying March 10, 2015 Transition Plan Order (October 29, 2021)